Carmel Tried to Defund Tourism Marketing. The Real Fight Is Management.
The council withheld $293,000 from See Monterey, then paid it anyway. The money was never the problem; managing the crowds it buys is.
The views expressed in this opinion are the author's own.

This summer Carmel's City Council did the thing angry residents have begged for for years. On June 2 it passed a $42 million budget for the 2026-2027 fiscal year that left out the city's expected $292,947 contribution to See Monterey, the countywide tourism bureau.
Five weeks later, on July 6, the council voted to put the money back. Nearly $293,000 went to See Monterey after the bureau's president and CEO, Rob O'Keefe, promised that part of it would pay for a visitor management study. The second vote, not the first, was the honest one. The council never really believed Carmel has too much marketing. It just needed somewhere to aim the frustration before admitting the real problem.

That frustration is real and it deserves more respect than the budget theater gave it. Councilmember Hans Buder, describing the barrage of complaints from residents, put it plainly: "People are angry about it. They're over it." The village has about 3,100 residents and on any given weekend the arithmetic of crowds, parking, traffic and trash does not work. When the people who live here say the town feels overwhelmed every single week, the correct response is not to quarrel with a line item. It is to manage the visitors who keep coming whether or not anyone advertises for them.
The uncomfortable truth the July vote acknowledged is that Carmel's visitor economy does not depend on a See Monterey ad buy. County tourism spending reached an estimated $3.3 billion in 2025, up 4.2 percent, generating $346 million in tax revenue. People come because the place is beautiful and famous, not because a bureau bought banner ads. Cutting $293,000 in marketing would not have emptied the sidewalks. It would only have left the city poorer and the crowds unmanaged.
Former councilmember and hotelier Bobby Richards said it best when the debate was at its peak: he was concerned that the discussion was focused on marketing, rather than management. That distinction is the entire ballgame. A village of Carmel's size needs the management question answered far more urgently than the marketing one, and the July deal, for all its clumsiness, pointed the money at the right question.
In August more than 150 residents packed Carpenter Hall at Sunset Center for a town hall organized by the Carmel Residents Association, Visit Carmel and the Carmel Chamber of Commerce, part of a task force effort to build what is being called the "Experience Management Plan for Carmel-by-the-Sea." The consultant, Cathy Ritter of Better Destinations, told the room that the only solutions that work come from the community. When the audience named its challenges, the top answer was parking, followed by traffic, crowds, trash, safety and noise.

That list is the agenda, and none of its answers appears in a marketing budget, which is why the June vote felt good and accomplished nothing, and why the July vote felt like a retreat but may turn out to be the useful one, if the study it funded actually changes how the village absorbs its visitors.
One caveat deserves daylight. The management plan is being financed in part by the same See Monterey money the council nearly withheld, so residents should hold the task force to Ritter's own standard: the solutions must come from the community, not from the bureau whose business is more visitors. If the plan that emerges reads like a marketing strategy with a new cover, the anger Buder described will not fade. It will organize.
Carmel did not need fewer tourists. It needs to be better at being visited. The council spent the summer learning the difference in public, at full volume, and at some cost to its credibility. The least the village can ask is that the lesson sticks: stop fighting the advertising and start managing the experience. That was always the fight that mattered.
We correct errors promptly and note them here. Send corrections through the contact form on our contact page.
