Il Fornaio to Pay $3 Million in EEOC Settlement, With Carmel Restaurant Named in Allegations
The federal agency announced Oct. 13 that the 15-location chain will pay $3 million to settle a sexual harassment and retaliation lawsuit brought on behalf of a class of female employees. Monterey County NOW reported allegations tied to the chain's Carmel restaurant. The company denies the allegations.

Il Fornaio will pay $3 million to settle a federal sexual harassment and retaliation lawsuit, and the Carmel restaurant at Ocean Avenue and Monte Verde Street is one of the locations named in the allegations behind the case. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission announced on Oct. 13 that Il Fornaio (America) LLC, an Italian restaurant chain with 15 locations in California and Nevada, will pay $3,000,000 and provide other relief to settle the suit, which the agency brought on behalf of a class of female employees. Nation's Restaurant News and HR Dive reported the same settlement terms from the agency's announcement.
Il Fornaio has denied the allegations. According to Monterey County NOW, the company denied all of the allegations against it, including those originating from the Carmel location, and said in court documents that it took reasonable steps to prevent harassment and corrective action and denies a larger pattern of discrimination or harassment. HR Dive's account of the three-year consent decree likewise records that the company denied the allegations, asserted that it took reasonable steps to prevent harassment, and that the decree is not an admission of liability or an adjudication of wrongdoing.

According to the EEOC, supervisors and employees across the chain's locations repeatedly subjected female employees, many of them teenagers, to sexual harassment that included forceful groping in restaurant bathrooms, multiple instances of grabbing female employees' private parts, requests for sexual favors and explicit references to sexual activities. The agency said the women complained about the harassment, but Il Fornaio failed to stop it and retaliated against many of them, and that several women had no choice but to resign.
"Sexual harassment continues to be a widespread issue in the restaurant industry, and during this case, we learned of at least 100 women negatively affected by Il Fornaio's work environment," said Beatriz B. Andre, acting regional attorney for the EEOC's Los Angeles District, in the agency's announcement. "Through this settlement, we hope Il Fornaio will take meaningful steps to prevent sexual harassment and respond promptly and effectively when complaints arise." Nation's Restaurant News carried the same statement from Andre.
The alleged conduct violates Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits a hostile work environment based on sex, including sexual harassment, and retaliation against people who complain, the EEOC said. The agency filed suit, EEOC v. Il Fornaio (America) LLC, Case No. 2:22-cv-05992, in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California in 2022, after first attempting to reach a pre-litigation settlement through its conciliation process.
Monterey County NOW reported that the company settled with the EEOC on Oct. 6, on claims that, since 2015, management and employees across the chain ignored and perpetuated sexual harassment toward female employees, including teenagers, leading to their resignations. The Weekly placed several of the allegations at the Carmel location. It reported that, at the Carmel restaurant in 2022, a kitchen worker allegedly sent sexual messages to a 17-year-old female hostess, and a manager allegedly dismissed her complaints. The Weekly also reported an earlier allegation from 2018, in which two male servers allegedly asked a hostess if they could see her vagina; she quit after complaining to management, who allegedly responded, "This could be your last day."

At least one of the managers accused of dismissing sexual harassment reports still works at the Carmel location, according to the Weekly, which confirmed his presence when he answered a call from the newspaper. He declined to comment and directed questions to the corporate office. Matt Foley, the company's director of marketing and creative services, declined to share details on current employees at the Carmel location, the Weekly reported.
"Il Fornaio takes harassment seriously and will continue to do everything possible to prevent and eliminate harassment in the workplace against all workers," Foley said in a statement carried by HR Dive. "The company prides itself on fostering a positive working environment for its employees, which is reflected in the high number of long-term employees and low turnover rate for the industry." Foley added that the chain entered into the settlement "to avoid the burden, expense, and uncertainty of continued litigation, and has increased its efforts to prevent and eliminate harassment and discrimination of all kinds in the workplace." He told the Weekly in similar terms that the company entered the settlement to avoid the expenses of continued litigation and had increased its efforts against harassment and discrimination.
Under the three-year consent decree, the company's human resources staff must attend three hours of live, interactive training, in person, each year for three years, stressing their obligation to report and act on potential or actual harassing behavior and to investigate complaints, according to HR Dive's account of the decree. Managerial and supervisory employees, including general managers, assistant managers, chefs and sous chefs, must receive similar training, HR Dive reported.
The Carmel restaurant is listed on the company's own site at Ocean Avenue at Monte Verde Street, and its listing on OpenTable places it in the historic Pine Inn Hotel. The chain is a 15-unit company owned by Tokyo-based Create Restaurant Group and based in Corte Madera, California, according to Nation's Restaurant News. The Carmel location is one of the restaurants in the chain that will operate under the decree's three-year training terms.
We correct errors promptly and note them here. Send corrections through the contact form on our contact page.

