Council Sides With Neighbors, Orders Rooftop Deck Removed From Carmelo Street Project
At its Sept. 1 meeting, the council directed staff to draft a resolution granting the appeal against a rooftop deck above an accessory dwelling unit.

This article is based on a published meeting summary of the Sept. 1, 2026 session of the Carmel-by-the-Sea City Council. All of the account that follows comes from that summary.
According to the meeting summary, the City Council directed staff to draft a resolution granting the appeal filed by Bruce and Linda Taylor against the McWhorter project on Carmelo Street. The effect of the decision was to remove the proposed rooftop deck above the project's accessory dwelling unit, which the appellants argued would harm their privacy and views.

The summary reports that city staff had recommended denying the appeal, which would have allowed the project, including the rooftop deck, to move forward as proposed. The council rejected that recommendation. Instead, according to the meeting summary, a majority of the council found that the deck's privacy and view impacts warranted its removal from the project.
The appellants' counsel argued, according to the summary, that the rooftop deck would alter the beach view from the Fraser House and effectively convert the roof into active living space. The privacy and view arguments proved decisive: the council's direction to staff was to eliminate the deck while allowing the rest of the project to proceed.
According to the meeting summary, the remainder of the McWhorter project was not at issue in the council's action. The appeal targeted the rooftop deck specifically, and the council's grant of the appeal leaves the rest of the project intact. The outcome represents a compromise between the project's overall approval and the neighbors' objections to its most contentious element.
The decision also illustrates the weight that view and privacy concerns carry in Carmel-by-the-Sea land use disputes. According to the summary, the council treated the Fraser House's beach view and the appellants' privacy as interests substantial enough to override both the staff recommendation and the applicant's design. In a village where views are treated as a kind of civic asset, that calculus is a familiar one.

What the council has not yet done is make the decision final. According to the meeting summary, the formal resolution granting the appeal was to return to the council at a later meeting, meaning the Sept. 1 action was a direction to staff rather than the adoption of the resolution itself. The draft resolution will come back for the council's formal approval before the deck's removal is official.
Until that resolution returns, the Carmelo Street project sits in a holding pattern: the rooftop deck is marked for removal by the council's direction, the rest of the project may proceed, and the appellants have won the substance of their appeal pending the paperwork. The meeting summary gives no date for the resolution's return, only that it would come before the council at a later meeting.
The form of the Sept. 1 action matters as much as its substance. According to the meeting summary, the council did not adopt a final resolution on the spot; it instructed staff to draft one and bring it back. That two-step process is how the council builds a record for appeal decisions, and it means the Taylors' victory, while clear in direction, remains technically provisional until the council votes the resolution into its official record at that later meeting.
We correct errors promptly and note them here. Send corrections through the contact form on our contact page.


